11 Tips for Buying at Yard Sales and Selling on eBay

We look at basics like scheduling, haggling, and conducting research.
yard sale

So you wanna be an eBay flipper, huh?

In the broadest sense, a "flipper" is someone who buys things cheap, and then sells for a profit, often on eBay. We've previously told you about a few yard sale finds that are likely to return a profit. There are many places where sellers acquire such items, but yard sales are a great place to start.

Is it as easy as buying someone's trash and selling it as treasure? Well, yes and no. To profit big and to profit regularly takes skill and dedication. (That's especially true now, when everyone knows about eBay.)

If you're a yard sale newbie, you're at a disadvantage. You don't know the intricacies, and a great many of them can only be learned through experience. Even so, there are plenty of tips that will help you avoid rookie mistakes.

Here are 11 things we wish we'd known when we first started. Consider this a crash course for true beginners!

The Early Bird Catches the Worm

If you're serious about this, realize that you're up against full-time professionals who will do anything to beat you to a score. Plan on getting up bright and early. After all, if you're the first person to hit a yard sale, you'll have the pick of the litter. Get there too late, and chances are good that somebody else will have already grabbed the best items.

Map It Out!

You can find yard sale listings online and in your local paper long before the weekend hits. Map out your "plan of attack" before you head out. Figure out how to hit the most yard sales with the least amount of driving. You'd be surprised at how many frustrating miles you'll waste otherwise — even if you're limiting the hunt to your nearest neighborhoods!

Do NOT Be Afraid to Haggle

In general, the people running yard sales are open to haggling. They expect it, so don't be shy. If they want three dollars, offer two. If there are a whole bunch of things you intend to buy, make a "bulk offer" for all of them.

The worst they can say is "no." If they're offended by your offer, take solace in knowing that you'll probably never see them again. Remember, a penny saved is a penny earned.

SEE ALSO: Yes, You CAN Shop Around and Haggle for Medical Procedures

Carry Plenty of Singles

Oh, and speaking of haggling! The easiest way to get a seller to accept your offer is by pretending you're not carrying any more money. That's hard to do if you only have tens and twenties, so make sure you're armed with lots of singles. "I only have three dollars" goes a lot further than "Can you break a $20 bill?"

(Yes, I'm advising you to lie. Don't worry, there are plenty of yard sale sellers who will lie right back. It's all part of the game.)

eBay on phone

The eBay Phone App Is Your Friend

If you're looking at a pricier item and don't want to risk buying a dud, sneak off for a moment and check the eBay app on your phone. Look up the item, and then look up its "completed listings." This is a great way to see if the item sells, and if so, for how much.

Sure, it's a little awkward to fumble around with an app while you're out hunting, but sometimes the hassle is warranted. Just don't do this for every cheap item you come across — you'll drive yourself crazy. Reserve this trick for the big risks.

Know When to Hold 'Em, Know When to Fold 'Em

More so than ever before, the people running yard sales are convinced that everything they're selling is a "collectible." Trust your own instincts, and don't buy the hype.

Be wary of the hard sell. When sellers give you long, unsolicited defenses of their prices, it's a telltale sign you'll be spending too much.

Be wary of the hard sell. When sellers give you long, unsolicited defenses of their prices, it's a telltale sign you'll be spending too much. If some guy wants $20 for broken doorknobs, and he has a prepared speech detailing why he must charge $20 for broken doorknobs, it's time for you to go.

Think About Future Expenses

If you're aiming to sell your finds on eBay, consider the reality of it. Sure, you could sell that $2 board game for $10, but is the profit worth the hassle? You'd have to find a box large enough to send it in. You'd have to research to make sure it's complete. All of these things take time, and if you're spending too much time and effort, suddenly those few dollars hardly seem worth it.

When considering a purchase, always imagine what it would be like to list and ship it. Is it too big or heavy? Is it easily breakable? Is a set possibly incomplete? Certain items are worth these risks and hassles, but not all of them.

phone camera

Stay Within Your Expertise

In time, you'll develop a sort of "sixth sense." You'll know what's likely to sell and what's likely to bomb, no matter how esoteric the item. Enough trial-and-error can turn anyone into an expert.

But developing that eye takes time. In the beginning, it's better to focus on your areas of expertise. If you have a passion for, say, vintage clothing, then you probably already know which old shirts are worth money, and which aren't.

SEE ALSO: You Won't Believe How Much You'll Save Thrift Shopping for Clothes

I'm not saying to never stray outside your comfort zone, because you'll have to. But at least try to stick with what you know, and only buy things that are foreign to you when they're cheap.

(One of the biggest mistakes new flippers make is thinking every old thing is worth money. Trust me: 90% of what you'll see out there is worth exactly what you'll pay for it.)

Outside Your Expertise, Play It Safe

Eventually — or perhaps even immediately — you're gonna start buying things you know little about. My previous tip warned against this, but it's still a natural part of the process. You might make a few mistakes, but what you'll learn from those mistakes will be invaluable later.

Still, there are some safe bets. Old video games (1990s or earlier), old coins, old action figures in decent condition (especially if they're from the '80s), and movie memorabilia are all good picks — if they're cheap, of course!

A broader tip: When you spot something, ask yourself whether anyone actually collects that type of item. Lots of people collect toys and coins, but there aren't nearly as many people buying up used blenders.

If It's Trash, Trash It

Look, you're going to end up with a few duds. This is unavoidable. Not everything you buy will be worth selling, and that's the price of doing business.

You're going to end up with a few duds. I cannot emphasize this enough: Get rid of those items.

I cannot emphasize this enough: Get rid of those items. If they can be donated, donate them. If they can't, introduce them to your garbage pail. If you don't do this, you'll soon find yourself dedicating entire rooms to things you neither want nor are able to sell. You've seen Hoarders, right? Don't let yard sales turn you into one of those people.

Prioritize Having Fun, Not Getting Rich

It's possible to turn yard sale flipping into a full-time job, but only with a combination of total dedication, natural aptitude, and a bunch of luck. If it was easy to get to that level, there'd be many more full-time resellers.

Chances are, you won't become one of them. So don't bother looking at that as the goal. Look at yard sales as a way to make a little side money from a hobby. You're getting out of the house, getting some fresh air, and getting the voyeuristic thrill of sifting through total strangers' material lives. Let that be the reward, and consider any profits an added bonus.

Reader, are you an eBay flipper? Have some other tips for people new to the yard sale game? Share them in the comments!

Matt Dracula
Contributing Writer

Matt has been blogging about geeky nonsense since early 2000. You can view more of his weird work on Dinosaur Dracula, or follow him on Twitter @dinosaurdracula.
DealNews may be compensated by companies mentioned in this article. Please note that, although prices sometimes fluctuate or expire unexpectedly, all products and deals mentioned in this feature were available at the lowest total price we could find at the time of publication (unless otherwise specified).


Leave a comment!

or Register
I've been doing this for years. Since 1999 actually. We are able to pay for all our vacations this way. A great way to start is sell what you already have. Zero investment that way. Heavy items can go in a flat rate box. USPS will ship them for free right to your door. Stay away from glass unless it's really, really worth it because you'll have to pay for insurance and extra to mark the item as fragile. I always ship clothes first class -- in just a simple manilla envelope. You can get a pack of 25 at Walmart for around $3. Baby clothes do great in "lots." Stick to high-end brands -- the other stuff is just too easy to get. But if you find a Burberry shirt at Goodwill, you WILL make money. Research those high-end brands. If we're out-of-town in a fishing community, I go to Goodwill looking for fishing shirts; a golf community, golf shirts. You get the idea. It's fun. It doesn't take a lot of time. And if you're persistent, you'll start to figure it out and make some money.
"Gonna?" Since when does that qualify as proper English? Save that vernacular for your texts, not a published article.
Also when you collecting through Paypal they add on 3% for transaction fee then add on shipping cost of USPS, UPS... and your time :(
Don't forget FeeBay charges nearly 15% for selling on their sight. They have many hidden fees that if you are not careful can nibble away at your profit.