Sign In

How to Get Comfortable Women's Shoes That Last

The priciest shoes aren't always the best for your feet. From heels to boots, we show you how to find great footwear at every price point.
women's shoes

While American women own about 17 pairs of shoes on average, they often only wear three or four pairs on a regular basis. The majority sit unused in the back of the closet. But if we're willing to spend hard-earned money on heels, why aren't we making use of them? Here's a theory: They're too dang uncomfortable!

We'll show you how to find quality women's footwear and what you'll get at different price points.

The 4 Main Shoe Components

Your shoes are made up of four key components that determine whether you'll be wearing them for years, or tossing them out.


For the longest-lasting and most comfortable wear, look for good quality suede or leather shoes. Leather allows your foot to "breathe," helping it feel more comfortable and reducing odors. Leather also stretches, conforming to the size and shape of your foot, according to podiatrist Dr. Jaleh Hoorfar. Fabric won't do that. And if you purchase a quality, soft leather, your shoes will last for years.

SEE ALSO: These 2 Features Help Men's Dress Shoes Last Forever

Watch out for synthetic leather. It looks good on the shelf — most synthetics are shiny and appealing at first — but the fake stuff breaks down quicker, meaning you'll be forever buying uncomfortable, short-lived shoes.

Inner Sole

The inner sole provides arch support and much-needed padding. You can buy shoe inserts for added cushioning, but not all inserts are created equal. You're better off choosing a shoe that doesn't need the added support.

First, look for shoes with good arch support — no easy task. Podiatrist Dr. Steve Rosenberg says most fashion-geared shoes don't provide adequate support. To tell if yours do, look for padding that's thicker around the edges and where your arch naturally fits in the shoe.

To tell if your shoes provide adequate support, look for padding that's thicker around the edges and where your arch naturally fits in the shoe.

Next, see that the heel and ball of your foot have good cushioning, especially if you're looking for heels. High heels naturally push the foot forward, adding pressure to the balls of your feet and causing pain in your feet, legs, and lower back.

Finally, make sure you're picking up the right size, which varies from brand to brand. According to Dr. Rosenberg, you should be able to fit at least a thumb's width between the end of your toes and the tip of your shoe. If you can't, good cushioning won't be enough to prevent pain.

Outer Sole

The outer sole of your shoe makes a big difference. A lot of modern styles don't have enough bottom padding (we're looking at you, ballet flats). This is bad news for two reasons: First, thin soles won't protect your feet from the ground. Second, thin soles wear out quicker, sending you back to the shoe store sooner.

That said, soles are best tested in person. Experts at Harvard Medical School suggest trying out new shoes on different types of surfaces — tile, carpet, concrete — to see how the shoes feel on each. If all else fails, go with wedges. Most wedges have plenty of shock-absorbing padding.

Heel Height

High heels do a number on your feet, from pain, to bunions, to lasting medical conditions. But that doesn't mean you have to live your life in flats. Some heels are fine, as long as you're careful with what you buy.

Look for padding underneath the tip of the heel. Rubber or plastic caps help prevent the heel from wearing out too quickly.

Dr. Hoorfar told O, The Oprah Magazine that her limit is 3" — anything higher and you'll be putting a ton of pressure on the balls of your feet. Opt for thicker heels over those needle-thin stilettos. (Thicker heels last longer than thin ones and are easier to walk in.) Also, look at the placement of the heel: Heels placed squarely under your actual heel distribute your weight better, Hoorfar says. Avoid ones placed all the way at the back of the shoe.

Finally, look for padding underneath the tip of the heel. Rubber or plastic caps help prevent the heel from wearing out too quickly.

What You'll Get at Every Price Point

Women's shoes vary widely in price, but not necessarily in design. In other words, expensive shoes aren't always your best bet, though certain price ranges can give you an idea of what you're getting.

$10 to $50: Mass-Market Brands and Discounted Styles

The majority of full-priced shoes in the $10 to $50 range aren't designed to last very long and lack support. If you do opt for these shoes, plan on buying additional padded inserts. However, you can also find deep discounts on some brand-name shoes in this price range, through retailers like 6pm and DSW.

$50 to $100: Midrange Brands

You'll find many recognizable brands at this price point, but don't expect a name to mean quality. Since lots of women's shoes are designed for fashion over comfort, anything you buy still needs to run the gamut of quality tests.

SEE ALSO: 5 Items You Can Buy Once (And They'll Last)

$100 to $150: Genuine Leather Shoes

You can find some genuine leather in this price range, but watch out for topstitching. Hoorfar says it can make leather less elastic, and thus less comfortable. Expect shoes in this tier to last through at least a couple of years of regular use (if they're comfortable).

$150 and Up: High-End Brands and Custom Shoes

Most high-end kicks run at least $150, though many can cost much more for even basic styles. But again, don't fall for the label. While high-end shoes are often built better than their cheap counterparts, even $500 boots don't always deliver on comfort. Always check your shoes for adequate padding, heel height, and design before you buy.

Readers, what women's shoe brands do you think provide a great value for the money? How do you usually shop for shoes: in-store or online? Let us know in the comments below!

Contributing Writer

Angela Colley has covered everything from money saving technology to how the Mayans might affect your savings. She’s appeared on publications like MainStreet and MSN Money. You can follow her on Twitter @angelancolley.
DealNews may be compensated by companies mentioned in this article. Please note that, although prices sometimes fluctuate or expire unexpectedly, all products and deals mentioned in this feature were available at the lowest total price we could find at the time of publication (unless otherwise specified).
You might also like
Leave a comment!

or Register
1 comment

Munro shoes! It's a family business and they are still made in the U.S. And they last -- my wife kept wearing her first pair far longer than any other shoes she's had, but she liked them too much to give up on them.