Used Gaming & Toy Deals

Collectors focused on early-2010s NFL cards or Josh Freeman specifically will find this a fairly niche pickup, as the Five Star line was Topps' premium tier with low print runs and higher-end stock compared to base sets. Buy Now at Fanatics

Collectors focused on Markquis Nowell or players who track rookie-era insert sets will find this one worth a look, as The Finals Ticket is one of the more sought-after parallels in the Contenders lineup. Buy Now at Fanatics

A solid pickup for Titans fans or collectors focused on late-90s NFL cards, as Kevin Dyson is one of the more recognizable names from that era given his role in Super Bowl XXXIV. Buy Now at Fanatics

Aimed at collectors focused on current NBA prospects, this is a Red parallel from Panini Mosaic Fast Break, which tends to carry more scarcity than base cards in the same set. Ron Holland II is in his rookie season, so cards like this tend to move in value as his role with the Pistons develops. Buy Now at Fanatics

Aimed at NFL collectors focused on rookie-era cards, this Deuce Vaughn parallel sits in the Panini Contenders Optic line, with the Purple Pulsar finish being a more limited variant than the base version. Buy Now at Fanatics

A niche pick for NFL collectors focused on rookie cards, as Laube is a 2024 draft pick and Prizm Red Shimmer parallels are among the more limited print runs in the Prizm lineup. Buy Now at Fanatics

Game-used jerseys are for collectors who want something with a direct connection to a specific player and moment, rather than a replica worn only on the couch. This one comes from the Utah Mammoth's inaugural 2025-26 season, which adds some historical context given how new the franchise is. Buy Now at Fanatics

Game-used jerseys are for collectors who want something tied directly to on-court action rather than a replica, and Cade Cunningham is the face of the Pistons rebuild, which makes his jersey a more relevant piece than most team memorabilia right now. Buy Now at Fanatics

Game-used jerseys are one of the more tangible ways to own a piece of NHL history, and this one comes with the added context of the Rangers' centennial season, making it more collectible than a standard game-worn piece. Worth a look if you're a Rangers fan who wants something with a direct connection to the ice rather than a replica. Buy Now at Fanatics

Fanatics has this Mika Zibanejad game-used, autographed Rangers jersey for collectors who want a piece of authenticated on-ice memorabilia rather than a standard replica. Game-used and signed together in one item is relatively uncommon, so it suits someone building a serious Rangers or Zibanejad collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Game-used, broken bats like this one appeal to collectors who want a piece of actual on-field equipment rather than a mass-produced memorabilia item. Fanatics has this Ryan McMahon Louisville Slugger for those looking to add a tactile, authenticated piece of Rockies history to a collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Numbered to just 25 copies, this card features one of Bowman Chrome's more visually distinct refractor variants alongside a certified autograph, which makes it a reasonable pick for collectors focused on low-population prospect autos. Buy Now at Fanatics

Rookie-year cards from LaMelo Ball's 2020-21 Select set are among the more actively traded in modern basketball card collecting, and the Prizm Red White Orange Shimmer parallel is a numbered variant that tends to hold its appeal with collectors focused on his early run. Buy Now at Fanatics

A rookie auto of Nicolo Melli numbered to 50, which puts it in the low-print category for collectors focused on the 2019-20 Panini Obsidian set or NBA players who had European careers before coming to the league. Buy Now at Fanatics

A solid pick for collectors focused on Jamal Murray, with the red Prizm parallel being one of the more visually distinct variants in the Choice format, which uses a different card stock and typically carries lower print runs than base Prizm. Buy Now at Fanatics

Rookie jersey cards from this era tend to hold collector interest, and Aaron Gordon's 2014-15 Panini Threads Jumbo Materials card includes an embedded swatch of game-used material, which is the main draw for anyone building a Gordon collection or picking up NBA rookie memorabilia cards. Buy Now at Fanatics

Scoot Henderson's Jade Dragon Scale parallel is one of the more visually distinct cards from this year's Prizm release, and it's the kind of low-print-run rookie card that collectors focused on building a Henderson PC tend to prioritize early. Buy Now at Fanatics

Game-used footballs are for collectors who want something tied to an actual play, not just a replica — this one comes directly from a Miami Hurricanes vs. Stanford Cardinal matchup, so it carries a specific game's history rather than just a team logo. Buy Now at Fanatics

Zion Williamson's rookie cards from the Prizm Luck of the Lottery insert set are among the more sought-after cards from his debut season, and this one tends to hold its value for collectors focused on modern NBA rookies. Worth picking up if you're building a Zion PC or want a recognizable card from one of the more hyped NBA draft classes in recent memory. Buy Now at Fanatics