Best Fanatics Deals & Sales for September 2026

Rookie card collectors and Ohio State/Cardinals fans will want this one for the 35th Anniversary Score set commemorating Marvin Harrison Jr.'s entry into the NFL, a nice pickup while his rookie cards are still fresh on the market. Buy Now at Fanatics

Card collectors chasing scarcer parallels will want this one, since the Longevity Silver variant of Byrd's rookie card is tougher to track down than the base version and adds a bit more upside for anyone building out a 2009 Donruss set. Buy Now at Fanatics

Baseball card collectors chasing Starlin Castro's early Cubs-era inserts will want this yellow parallel from the 2014 Bowman set for its scarcer print run compared to the base card. Buy Now at Fanatics

Baseball card collectors who track advanced metrics rather than just batting stats will appreciate this Familia card, since it highlights his relief pitching numbers instead of the usual counting stats. It's a niche pickup for Mets fans or set completists rounding out their 2019 Topps Advanced Stats collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Football card collectors chasing 90s inserts will recognize the Gridiron Gold parallel as a tougher pull from the Pinnacle Inside set, making this Anthony Johnson card a nice pickup for Falcons or Colts collections. It's a solid option for set builders working through 1997 Pinnacle Inside rather than a piece aimed at casual fans. Buy Now at Fanatics

Baseball card collectors chasing pink parallels or All-Star subsets will want to check this one out, especially if you're building a Mark Melancon PC. Fanatics has it listed for anyone looking to add a low-numbered variant to their collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Kris Bryant collectors will appreciate this relic card for the game-worn material piece tied to the retro '86 Topps design, making it a solid pickup for anyone building out a player collection rather than just chasing base cards. Buy Now at Fanatics

Baseball card collectors focused on late-90s Pacific Gold inserts will want this one for the set-building value, especially those tracking Cascadden's run. Buy Now at Fanatics

Rookie card collectors will want this one for the Diamante set's shine, since it tracks Chaz Lanier's early season as a rookie worth watching. Buy Now at Fanatics

Card collectors chasing parallel variations will want this one for the orange foil finish, which adds scarcity beyond the base 2024 Topps set. Buy Now at Fanatics

Baseball card collectors chasing scarce parallels will want to note the Silver limited-print run on this one, which sets it apart from the standard Timeless Tributes issue. It's a niche pickup for Jimmy Williams collectors or anyone building out this specific 2006 Donruss Classics insert set. Buy Now at Fanatics

Worth a look for Chiefs collectors or rookie card investors, since Prizm parallels like this Light Blue #185 tend to hold appeal beyond the base set. Buy Now at Fanatics

This is a solid pick for collectors chasing scarce Artist's Proof parallels, since limited print runs like this one tend to hold appeal even for players outside the mainstream superstar tier. Buy Now at Fanatics

Fits well for set collectors chasing the O-Pee-Chee Black Mini parallel specifically, since Pence's rookie-era cards from this insert run don't turn up often in this condition. Buy Now at Fanatics

Basketball card collectors chasing scarcer autographed inserts will want to note this one, as the Modern Marks Red parallel signals a limited print run tied to Danilo Gallinari's career. Fanatics carries it for those building out Immaculate Collection sets or looking for a signed piece from his time in the league. Buy Now at Fanatics

Sports card collectors chasing scarce parallels will want this one, since Platinum Holofoil parallels typically carry lower print runs than the base Gridiron Gear set. It's a solid pickup for Larry Johnson fans or anyone rounding out a 2006 Donruss collection with harder-to-find inserts. Buy Now at Fanatics

Worth a look for Cleanthony Early collectors or set builders chasing the Press Proofs Blue parallel, since limited-run rookie cards like this one tend to get harder to track down as time goes on. Buy Now at Fanatics

Sports card collectors chasing game-used memorabilia will appreciate this one, since it pairs a Sinorice Moss patch swatch with the low print runs typical of the Rookies and Stars set. Buy Now at Fanatics

Card collectors and Buccaneers fans rounding out a Ronde Barber collection will want to check out this Score card, a budget-friendly option compared to his rarer inserts and rookie cards. Buy Now at Fanatics