Yay or Nay to Autopay: When Automatic Bill Payment Goes Horribly Wrong


When it comes to paying recurring bills, signing up for automatic payments may seem like the easy — and responsible — way to go. It's a surefire way to have your payments delivered on time, and something that's not only good for building your credit score, but also for your peace of mind.

According to Gregory Karp, author of Living Rich by Spending Smart and The 1-2-3 Money Plan, the average consumer pays about 12 bills per month and Americans spend 22 hours per year paying bills. "Besides saving money on stamps and paper checks, [autopay] saves hassle," Karp told DealNews. "Life's too busy and time too short to devote loads of time to bill-paying."

But can the convenience of autopay backfire, making it conveniently easy to not keep track of your spending? Before signing up for automatic bill payments, consider these possible drawbacks.

Maintaining Your Bank Balance

First and foremost, you must maintain enough money in your bank account for autopay to be affective. This seems obvious, but the convenience of automatic payments requires that you keep a close eye on your bank account balance — and be aware of when the charges are slated to hit your account. For this reason, some financial experts recommend using automatic payments only for regularly recurring bills (i.e. a monthly utility bill versus a water bill that arrives every three months) and for bills that are always roughly the same amount (cable television, for example). Keep track of bills that can vary seasonally, such as gas and electric.

Additional Charges May Go Unnoticed

When you have an automatic bill pay for services like cable or wireless, it's easy to not notice an increase in fees, new surcharges, or even incorrect charges. "Just because you're autopaying doesn't mean you're not looking at bills and checking for errors and rate increases," Karp says. "I think people who switch to online billing can become complacent and do not check [charges] as often as they should."

Even subscriptions prices can change. Let's say you ignore reminder emails from services like Amazon's Subscribe & Save, which offer discounts on recurring purchases of things like toiletries and groceries. Losing track of your subscription at best means extra toothpaste and toilet paper. But, at worst, you could end up paying more than your original quoted purchase as time goes on if you aren't aware of these notifications.

Monthly Subscriptions Add Up

Do you already have great deal on a streaming music service and love your Dollar Shave Club membership plan, and now you're thinking about adding a premium cable channel? Before you do, check the total costs of the services you already pay for before subscribing to additional monthly memberships and subscriptions: combined they easily take a large bite out of your bank balance.

"I call it the curse of recurring payments — the gym membership, wine of the month club, streaming video service, premium cable channels," Karp says. When you're subscribing to services that automatically bill, Karp recommends looking over these charges quarterly and asking yourself if they're really necessary. "Be ruthless about cutting," he says. "You could always add it back if you find you miss it."

When Free Trials End

The idea behind a trial subscription to a magazine or a premium job networking site is that you'll enjoy it so much, you will continue as a paid subscriber. In some cases, it's easy to unsubscribe before you have to pay — just remember to mark the date on your calendar. Once some companies have your credit card or bank info, however, it can be more difficult to discontinue subscriptions. According to a PCWorld article, after a writer subscribed to 40 free trials, he found that more than one-fourth of them were difficult to quit, and three companies even charged his card despite cancellation.

Refunds Are Harder to Process

Once a company has your money, it's sometimes more difficult to get a refund. For example, if you sign up for a gym membership and don't receive the rate you were promised, you might be looking at a few months of disputes, or even offers from the company that aren't quite as good as the ones you initially signed up for.

If you're wary of a vendor, it's better to use a credit card versus a number tied to your bank account. "The ability to dispute a charge is definitely an advantage of using a credit card," says Karp.

Wrongful Charges Can Snowball

Incorrect charges — whether they be more than expected or completely unauthorized — are definitely inconveniences. What's worse, if your bank account is overcharged by a vendor, it can easily lead to overdraft fees that you'll have to pay. For example, earlier this year, a Dallas, Texas-based utility company accidentally withdrew 10 times the amount owed from the accounts of nearly 40,000 customers, who then had to wait 24 to 72 hours for a refund.

Keeping Your Accounts Up to Date

If your bank account changes or your credit card expires, change your billing information before you get failure notices. Be sure to provide current emails and phone number, and provide secondary emails and phone numbers if the option is available.

Convenience Fees Add Up

Some companies charge a convenience fee for automatic payments. However, this method is pretty unpopular with consumers, as Verizon Wireless discovered a few years ago; when the company proposed charging a $2 fee for autopay, its customers reacted with lots of negative feedback, and then promptly dropped the idea.

Provided you avoid these pitfalls, automatic payment is a viable option for many consumers. "The largest benefit is that you won't forget to pay the bill," Karp says. "Failing to pay could mean incurring late fees and wrecking your credit scores, not to mention that your lights might go dark if you don't pay the electric bill." Overall, he says, "I think the benefits outweigh the disadvantages." We agree, but do you, DealNews readers? Which services do you pay automatically and which do you prefer to pay manually? Do you do so online or by check? Tell us in the comments below.

Related DealNews Features:
Josie Rubio
Contributing Writer

Josie Rubio was a Brooklyn-based freelance editor and writer, who interviewed everyone from Britney Spears to ghost experts during her lengthy journalism career. She visited five continents, and loved to write about travel, food, nutrition, health, gardening... and pretty much everything.

Note: Josie Rubio died on December 3, 2019.
DealNews may be compensated by companies mentioned in this article. Please note that, although prices sometimes fluctuate or expire unexpectedly, all products and deals mentioned in this feature were available at the lowest total price we could find at the time of publication (unless otherwise specified).


Leave a comment!

or Register
I never let a payee *draw* from my account, rather I push payments only. Not much different, except that by pushing only, I control everything from the bank website.
I have had one serious problem. I was auto-paying my mortgage, and the escrow amount changed. So for 4 months I was paying about $40 too little. The mortgage company sent emails to an email address that I had stopped using. Bottom line, by the time I found out, they had reported 4 months of total delinquency in my mortgage payments. This hurt badly and cost me a lot of money. They refused to withdraw the reporting, even though they admitted that it was an understandable error.
So, apparently if you pay even $1.00 short, they consider it "not paying your mortgage". The mortgage company was "American Home Mortgage Servicing, Inc.", in case you are shopping.
I like the idea of autopay for recurring bills because the bills and checks cannot get lost in the mail, and if there is a problem, the fault lies with the vendor (except for the obvious things such as account balance and credit card expiration date). For those vendors who do not accept credit cards, I have a bank account set up specifically for automatic payments, keeping it totally separate from my main account, and only need to make one transfer per month into that account to cover the expenses. So far, after many years of this, I have never had a problem with my system.
I have set up billers automatically deduct from my credit cards, then after the end of billing cycle of these credit cards, i have my bank sends payments to these credit cards. I would never let any merchants withdraw any fund directly from my bank account.
Most of the negative examples cited for auto pay are rare and defy common sense. Auto pay is an authorization by the account holder the payment funds come from to the biller/merchant/utility that allows them to deduct the pre-authorized amount on the payment due date. A few suggestions for everyone -- only use auto-pay for regular bills (not promotional bills) -- water, gas, electricity, cable tv, cell phones, directv, credit card payments, etc. are the best ones. Also, paying the full amount due is most convenient if you can afford to do so -- the big exception here may be credit cards. Also, get rewarded for you payments -- use a rewards credit card versus a bank account for those billers that accept cards without a service fee -- typically cable tv, satellite tv, cell phone service -- and even some utility companies. Then, set up these credit card payments to be paid automatically from your bank accounts -- now you are really automated.