Black Friday Accounted for 70% of Cancelled Orders from the Past 2 Weeks

By , dealnews Features Director

Although people still showed up at brick-and-mortar stores in droves on Black Friday, the 2012 season was a success for online shopping. In fact, Black Friday itself racked up $1 billion in online sales, a new record and a 26% jump in sales from the year before. Cyber Monday e-commerce sales increased this year as well, by 17%.

However, despite these numbers, we heard rumblings amongst readers and accounts elsewhere online that all was not well with those who happily clicked "buy now" during the past two weeks. After making a purchase, many shoppers later signed into their email only to find that sinking message: that their order could not be fulfilled. Reportedly, Best Buy, Toys "R" Us, Fry's, and many others were forced to cancel orders because their systems oversold various items.

We decided to ask our readers how many of them had had an order cancelled from the weeks of Black Friday or Cyber Monday, and at the time of publishing, about 47% of those who voted indicated yes, they had. That's notably high, although this could be attributed to scorned shoppers being particularly motivated to partake in the poll. However, the data regarding when these people placed that order is intriguing.

As it turns out, 70% of those with cancelled orders had made their purchase during Black Friday week, while Cyber Monday week orders only accounted for 30% of the cancellations. While this ratio can still change — Best Buy, after all, was still cancelling Black Friday orders last year well into December — the vast disparity speaks to the differences in shopping on these days. Black Friday week is largely about big doorbuster electronics in extremely limited quantities, while Cyber Monday puts a greater emphasis on home goods and apparel. The latter items can certainly sell out, but the mind-boggling prices on electronics from Black Friday are more likely to get snapped up at a clip since they've been heavily advertised for weeks. It would seem that several retailers' sites just can't effectively match actual real-time stock to the flurry of incoming orders.

Regardless of the day, unfulfilled orders degrade the experience and make shoppers angry that they invested time price matching and purchasing specifically from one merchant over another. Many of the complaints that we received even expressed feeling hoodwinked by the vendor. Thus, if retailers want to build upon the unprecedented online growth from this Black Friday season, they should consider inspiring consumer trust by providing a system that actually delivers the goods.

Photo credit: InstanteStore

Follow @dealnews on Twitter for the latest roundups, price trend info, and stories. You can also sign up for an email alert for all dealnews features.
DealNews may be compensated by companies mentioned in this article. Please note that, although prices sometimes fluctuate or expire unexpectedly, all products and deals mentioned in this feature were available at the lowest total price we could find at the time of publication (unless otherwise specified).


Leave a comment!

or Register
I had no problems. I placed a few orders from Best Buy and Amazon.  I was even able to cancel 1 item at Best Buy and place a different order there on a better deal.  I was impressed how quickly Best Buy took care of the cancellation. I am really happy I received my orders.
No problems this year. Ordered from Best Buy, Amazon, and Game Stop. Orders were places as soon as deals went live.