DealNews - Best Fanatics Deals & Sales for September 2026

2022 Panini Prizm Star Gazing Mike Trout #2 Silver Prizm Card for $7.20

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:27:17 -0400

Trout collectors chasing the Silver Prizm parallel will want this Star Gazing insert for its refractor-style shine, and the low print numbering on this insert set makes it a reasonable pickup for set builders too. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2022 Panini Prizm Baseball insert card
Star Gazing insert set contains 15 cards
Features Mike Trout of the Los Angeles Angels
Silver Prizm parallel
Card number SG-2

2005 Leaf Rookies and Stars Longevity Black C.C. Brown #178 Trading Card for $9

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:27:04 -0400

Card collectors chasing scarce parallels will want to check this one out, since the Longevity Black parallel from this 2005 set is numbered and much tougher to track down than base rookie cards. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2005 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity football card
Black parallel serial-numbered to 50
C.C. Brown rookie card
Card number 178
Houston Texans player featured

2009 Playoff Prestige Kevin Curtis Card for $5.40

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:27:03 -0400

Football card collectors chasing vintage Playoff Prestige inserts will want to check this one out, especially Eagles or Wide Receiver fans looking for a piece of Kevin Curtis's career. Fanatics has it available if you're building out a 2009 set or just adding to a broader collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2009 Playoff Prestige football card
Kevin Curtis Philadelphia Eagles wide receiver
Prestigious Pros Blue parallel
Serial-numbered to 1,000 copies
Card number 25

2006 Donruss Threads Silver Holofoil Joey Harrington Card for $5

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:27:00 -0400

Fanatics has this one for collectors chasing scarce parallels rather than just the base player, since silver holofoil inserts from the 2006 Threads set are printed in limited numbers. It suits Detroit-era Joey Harrington fans or set builders looking to fill a specific holofoil slot. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2006 Donruss Threads football card
Joey Harrington pictured with the Miami Dolphins
Silver Holofoil parallel finish
Card number 42
Serial-numbered to 100 copies

2004 Upper Deck National Pride Rickie Weeks Jersey Card #42 for $7

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:47 -0400

Baseball card collectors chasing early-2000s prospect memorabilia will appreciate this one, since it pairs a Rickie Weeks jersey swatch with a numbered card from his rookie era. Fanatics carries it for those looking to fill out a Brewers or Milwaukee-era collection with a piece that combines both game-used material and card-collecting value. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2004 Upper Deck National Pride Uniforms Series One insert card
Rickie Weeks card numbered USA42
Features an embedded game-used jersey swatch
Short-printed issue within the 42-card jersey set
References Weeks as a Milwaukee Brewers player and USA Baseball alumnus

1996 Donruss Press Proofs #30 Troy Aikman for $7.20

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:36 -0400

Football card collectors chasing serialized 90s inserts will appreciate the limited print run behind this Aikman Press Proof, and it's a solid addition if you're building out a Cowboys or Hall of Fame quarterback collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

1996 Donruss Press Proofs football parallel
Troy Aikman Dallas Cowboys quarterback featured
Card number 30
Gold foil highlights and die-cut helmet accent
Print run limited to 2,000 cards

2007 Playoff Prestige Prestigious Pros Gold Ronnie Brown #14 Trading Card for $7.20

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:35 -0400

Card collectors chasing scarce gold parallels will want this one, since the Prestigious Pros Gold subset was produced in limited numbers back in 2007 and tends to hold appeal for Ronnie Brown or Dolphins-era memorabilia fans specifically. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2007 Playoff Prestige Prestigious Pros football insert
Gold parallel with gold PMS color variation
Serial-numbered to 25 copies
Features Miami Dolphins running back Ronnie Brown
Card number PP-14

2007 Leaf Rookies and Stars Silver Charles Johnson Card #128 for $5.40

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:23 -0400

Card collectors chasing serialized rookie-era inserts will appreciate this 2007 Leaf Rookies and Stars Silver Charles Johnson card, especially given the numbered scarcity that comes with the Silver parallel. It's a solid pickup if you're building out a Johnson collection or looking for a mid-2000s insert with some print-run rarity behind it. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

Silver Holofoil parallel card
Serial numbered to 199 copies
Charles Johnson rookie card
Features Carolina Panthers defensive end Charles Johnson
Card number 128 in the 2007 Leaf Rookies & Stars set

2018 Topps Factory Set Foilboard Starling Marte Card #60 for $8

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:09 -0400

Suits set-builders and Pirates collectors looking to fill out their 2018 Topps run, since the foilboard variant gives you a shinier alternative to the base card without straying from the original design. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

Foilboard parallel from 2018 Topps Baseball Complete Factory Set
Card #60 features Starling Marte of the Pittsburgh Pirates
Serial-numbered to 190 copies
Hobby factory set exclusive
Part of the 702-card 2018 Topps Baseball base set

2004 Leaf Press Proofs Blue Alex Rodriguez #284 Trading Card for $9

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:09 -0400

Serious A-Rod collectors chasing scarce parallels will want to know these Blue Press Proofs come from a limited print run, making card #284 a solid pickup for anyone building out a 2004 Leaf set. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2004 Leaf baseball card featuring Alex Rodriguez
Blue Press Proof parallel issued in hobby packs
Serial-numbered to 100 copies
Card number 284, designated TC
Features Alex Rodriguez as a Texas Rangers player

2002 Playoff Honors Jerramy Stevens Rookie Stallion Autograph Card for $14

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:08 -0400

Card and memorabilia collectors chasing early-2000s NFL rookie autographs will want to add this one to a Jerramy Stevens set, especially given how limited Rookie Stallion parallels tend to run compared to base autograph issues. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

Jerramy Stevens rookie football card
Sticker autograph included
Serial-numbered to 100 copies
Card number RS22
Seattle Seahawks team card

2020-21 Hoops Red Backs Anthony Davis Trading Card for $9

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:26:07 -0400

Anthony Davis fans and set collectors chasing the parallel Red Backs variant will want this one, since it's the kind of card that fills a specific spot in a Hoops build rather than a general pickup. Fanatics has it listed if you're trying to track one down. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2020-21 Panini NBA Hoops base set card
Anthony Davis of the Los Angeles Lakers
Red Back parallel variety
Card number 126
Officially licensed NBA basketball trading card

2014 Leaf Metal Draft Braxton Davidson Baseball Card for $5

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:52 -0400

Anyone chasing early prospect cards will appreciate this one, since Braxton Davidson's rookie-year draft card sits at that entry point before values shift one way or the other. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2014 Leaf Metal Draft baseball card
Features Braxton Davidson
On-card autograph
Short-print card
Card number BA-BD1

2003 Leaf Certified Materials Fabric of the Game Magglio Ordonez Jersey Card for $25

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:51 -0400

Baseball card collectors chasing game-worn memorabilia pieces will appreciate the embedded jersey swatch from Ordonez, and the "Fabric of the Game" line makes it a solid addition for anyone building out early-2000s Leaf Certified sets. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2003 Leaf Certified Materials Fabric of the Game insert
Magglio Ordonez Chicago White Sox card
Game-used jersey memorabilia swatch
Serial-numbered to 100 copies
Card number FG-107

2020-21 Panini Contenders Optic Black Pandora Seth Curry #64 Trading Card for $12

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:32 -0400

Card collectors chasing Seth Curry inserts will want this one for the Optic Black Pandora parallel, a limited-run finish that stands out from standard base cards. Fanatics has it available for anyone building out a Curry collection or looking to add a scarcer 2020-21 Contenders piece. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2020-21 Panini Contenders Optic basketball trading card ([beckett.com](https://www.beckett.com/basketball/2020-21/panini-contenders-optic-black-pandora/64-seth-curry-20751419?utm_source=openai))
Seth Curry Philadelphia 76ers Season Ticket card ([beckett.com](https://www.beckett.com/basketball/2020-21/panini-contenders-optic-black-pandora/64-seth-curry-20751419?utm_source=openai))
Black Pandora hobby-exclusive super short print parallel ([cardboardconnection.com](https://www.cardboardconnection.com/2020-21-panini-contenders-optic-basketball-cards?utm_source=openai))
Card number #64 ([beckett.com](https://www.beckett.com/basketball/2020-21/panini-contenders-optic-black-pandora/64-seth-curry-20751419?utm_source=openai))
Optichrome chromium card design ([cardboardconnection.com](https://www.cardboardconnection.com/2020-21-panini-contenders-optic-basketball-cards?utm_source=openai))

2024 Panini Mosaic Overdrive CJ Stroud #8 Card for $15

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:32 -0400

Football card collectors chasing rookie-era Stroud pieces will want this one for the Overdrive parallel, which stands out with its distinct visual pop compared to base Mosaic cards. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2024 Panini Mosaic Football Overdrive Mosaic insert
Ten-card Overdrive Mosaic checklist
Card number 8 features C.J. Stroud
Represents Houston Texans quarterback C.J. Stroud
Mosaic parallels include Blue /99, Purple /49, White /25, Gold /10, Black 1/1

2016 Prestige Byron Marshall Rookie Autograph Purple #14 for $10

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:15 -0400

Panthers rookie card collectors will want this one for the on-card autograph and the low-numbered purple parallel, which adds some scarcity to an already limited print run. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2016 Panini Prestige football trading card
Byron Marshall Philadelphia Eagles rookie card
Rookie Autographs Xtra Points Purple parallel
Sticker autograph included
Card #14, limited to 100 copies

2014-15 Panini Excalibur Crusade Orange Die-Cut Goran Dragic Card for $12

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:12 -0400

Basketball card collectors chasing scarce parallels will want to note the die-cut Orange Crusade variant, a numbered insert from Excalibur's 2014-15 set that's tougher to track down than the base version. Fanatics has it listed for those specifically hunting Goran Dragic memorabilia or filling out a Crusade parallel run. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2014-15 Panini Excalibur basketball card
Optichrome-enhanced Crusade insert
Orange Die-Cut parallel
Goran Dragic, Miami Heat, card #88
Serial numbered to 60 copies

1998 Finest Mystery Finest #M14 Nomar Garciaparra Trading Card for $18

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:25:01 -0400

Card collectors chasing 90s Finest inserts will recognize the Mystery Finest subset as one of the harder pulls from that era, and Garciaparra's rookie-adjacent years make this a name worth tracking down for any Red Sox or shortstop-focused collection. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

1998 Topps Finest Mystery Finest Series One insert
Card number M14 features Nomar Garciaparra for the Boston Red Sox
Opaque protective film conceals both sides until peeled away
Series One Mystery Finest insert set contains 50 cards
Base Mystery Finest inserts appear one per 36 hobby packs

2023 Topps Chrome Francisco Alvarez Blue Sonar Refractor Card for $15

Tue, 01 Sep 2026 23:24:59 -0400

Alvarez collectors and Mets fans will appreciate the Blue Sonar Refractor's numbered scarcity, which sets it apart from the base Chrome parallels most sellers carry. Buy Now at Fanatics

Features

2023 Topps Chrome Baseball rookie card
Card #203 features New York Mets catcher Francisco Álvarez
Blue Sonar Refractor parallel
Serial-numbered to 125 copies
Officially licensed MLB collectible