Cheers and Jeers of 2007

As the curtain begins to fall on 2007, we here at dealnews are taking a look back at the stores and events that created the biggest ripples of excitement throughout the year and those that caused the biggest let-downs. From deceptive promotions, to unbeatable bargains, we present you with our best and worst of 2007, based on your feedback and our personal experiences.

Cheers: To The Apple Store, for taking a definite Jeer and turning the table. Hundreds of dealnews readers (including two dealnews staffers) ordered refurbished iPod shuffles a few days before Christmas because of Apple's guaranteed delivery. However, when our staffers received confirmation emails from Apple, it stated that the iPods were shipped UPS Ground and would arrive on December 26. Christmas ruined? No! In one instance, Apple realized the mistake before the product was actually shipped, and the iPod arrived on Christmas Eve. In another instance, since the iPod has already shipped via Ground delivery, Apple sent out a second iPod, gratis, overnight for December 24 delivery. Well played!

Jeers: To OfficeMax, for being a Grinch and completely skipping the holiday season. and both offered free shipping on all orders through most of the holiday season; kept its minimum order of $50. Staples and Office Depot both had big Black Friday sales online; OfficeMax skipped Black Friday. It's not surprising that placed near the bottom in a recent online customer satisfaction study because of its perceived high prices.

Cheers: To, who undercut the competition this holiday season with its unbeatably low HDTV prices. Circuit City, Wal-Mart, Best Buy — all of these stores had solid Black Friday deals on HDTVs. That is, until Fry's came along and undercut the lot.

Jeers: To's Wednesday Sales. Have you noticed that we've stopped listing them? That's because they generally consist of two absolutely useless products. (We could swear we saw a dot-matrix printer ribbon during one sale.)

Cheers: To Linens 'n Things, for consistently churning out 20% off coupons, price cuts, and respectable shipping rates (often free). Although its delivery time tends to be on the slow side, its offer of in-store pickup was great for people who needed that pasta set by the end of the day.

Cheers: To, for having proved it still has what it takes to remain the online world's reliable shopping workhorse. Bonus points go out for its generous 30-day price guarantee, free Super Saver shipping, cut-throat competitiveness (like when it undercut Wal-Mart's Black Friday price on a KitchenAid mixer), and relative ease of requesting refunds. However ...

Jeers: To, who continued to confuse everyone by listing third-party merchants where you'd expect to find Amazon itself. This is an especially big hassle when Amazon itself sells out of a particular deal and substitutes another store that charges far more.

Cheers: To, for keeping a vast selection of products at below-average prices throughout the year. is a reader favorite because of its reliable shipping and consistent shopping experience.

Jeers: Last, but not least, a bucket-full of jeers to, for having sold items that were out of stock, leaving several customers clueless as to the whereabouts of the merchandise. We'd like to see better communication between customer service and the shipping department in the future and better policies for cancelling orders that can not ship in a timely manner.

Compiled by the editors and writers at dealnews who kept the deals slingin' throughout the holiday season.

DealNews may be compensated by companies mentioned in this article. Please note that, although prices sometimes fluctuate or expire unexpectedly, all products and deals mentioned in this feature were available at the lowest total price we could find at the time of publication (unless otherwise specified).


Leave a comment!

or Register