Walmart offers the SmartLab Toys All-Natural Lip Balm Boutique for $9.99. (Amazon charges the same.) Opt for in-store pickup to dodge the $5.99 shipping fee. That's the lowest price we could find by $2. It includes beeswax and molds to make lip balms and lotion bars.

Update: Both stores now charge $10.70. That drops to $10.32 when you choose pickup at Walmart, or when you add to cart at Amazon.